X-Wing Generics... Too Good now?

So…  I have been thinking a LOT about the X-Wing events going forward.  It is looking like there might have been an overcorrection WRT the generics vs the Aces.  Mind, this is NOT for individual ships I think.  When the ships get spammed however, the efficiencies become amplified I think.  Examples that I have seen recently are the S&V Mining TIEs with Drea in her Y-Wing and 5 Y-Wings with Ion Turrets...  These are being played locally, and frankly they are REALLY efficient.  The multiplier of Drea giving out re-rolls makes ANY Drea swarm really good…  Just having to keep the Target in one of the Arcs is not too hard and I think much better than the Imperial equivalent with Howlrunner…  Suspect the S&V Y-Wings would be better than the Rebel ones I’ve seen, but practicing for the Hyperspace events Rebel Y’s are the only ones out there.

One I heard about is:

Heavy Fighters (199)

Drea Renthal — BTL-A4 Y-Wing	42
Expert Handling	2
Dorsal Turret	2
Ship Total: 46
Half Points: 23 Threshold: 4
Lok Revenant — Scurrg H-6 Bomber	43
Dorsal Turret	2
Veteran Turret Gunner	6
Ship Total: 51
Half Points: 26 Threshold: 5
Lok Revenant — Scurrg H-6 Bomber	43
Dorsal Turret	2
Veteran Turret Gunner	6
Ship Total: 51
Half Points: 26 Threshold: 5
Lok Revenant — Scurrg H-6 Bomber	43
Dorsal Turret	2
Veteran Turret Gunner	6
Ship Total: 51
Half Points: 26 Threshold: 5

The lads on the Gold Squadron Podcast listed this off, more or less… I added the Expert Handling, but thinking perhaps the Seismic Charges might work well somewhere just to clear the board…  Just another hyper efficient generic list, and it just throws out a LOT of Damage if I can just line up and joust…  With 3 Medium Bases it is a fairly difficult Joust to avoid with the Barrel Roll just covering a LOT of space.

The Hyperspace list I am frankly thinking is going to be a rough one is:

Y Not? (200)

Gray Squadron Bomber — BTL-A4 Y-Wing	31
Ion Cannon Turret	4
Shield Upgrade	4
Proton Bombs	5
Veteran Turret Gunner	6
Ship Total: 50
Half Points: 25 Threshold: 5
Gray Squadron Bomber — BTL-A4 Y-Wing	31
Ion Cannon Turret	4
Shield Upgrade	4
Proton Bombs	5
Veteran Turret Gunner	6
Ship Total: 50
Half Points: 25 Threshold: 5
Gray Squadron Bomber — BTL-A4 Y-Wing	31
Ion Cannon Turret	4
Shield Upgrade	4
Proton Bombs	5
Veteran Turret Gunner	6
Ship Total: 50
Half Points: 25 Threshold: 5
Gray Squadron Bomber — BTL-A4 Y-Wing	31
Ion Cannon Turret	4
Shield Upgrade	4
Proton Bombs	5
Veteran Turret Gunner	6
Ship Total: 50
Half Points: 25 Threshold: 5

LOTS of Hull, Lots of shots every turn, nothing subtle, just line up and run at them trusting your ability to kill them first…  And of course bombs everywhere when you get in close…  Especially with the ability to bloody well Reload when they run out…  Degeneration everywhere J…

Mostly I am REALLY hoping that Wave 3 is out before the Hyperspace event in Bloomington 4 May…

X-Wing League, final run coming up...

So…  Got in 4 of my 6 League games.  First was just my Dash/Roark list to practice for the Bloomington event.  Next 3 were 2 B-Wings and Norra.  The first was the ARC and Sabine.  Successful, but felt like it was seriously lacking hitting power.  Last 2 were Braylen and Ten in their B-Wings with AP5 taxiing Leia and Norra in her Y-Wing to provide the hammer.  She WAS seriously overloaded with the R-3 mech, Vet Gunner, Proton Torpedoes AND Bombs to go along with the Ion Turret…  Think I can count on one hand the number of times I actually got to fire the bloody Ion turret and NEVER used the Gunner.  The Torpedoes and Bombs on the other hand…  THOSE were awesome.  The R-3 to give 2 TLs was nice, and having the Reload action in my pocket as it were meant I was not overly concerned about “holding” my Torpedoes if I had ANY shot.  The threat of the fully modified Proton Torpedo was enough to keep things like Fenn Rau REALLY cautious.  He and Guri dodged Arcs as often as they could to avoid Norra, and usually meant they had no shot, so that worked for me.  Braylen and Ten were solid work horses in the list.  USUALLY having the fully modified shot, and the FCS on Ten proved its worth I think.  In each game I dialed in Reds thinking I would activate Leia and have Actions, etc…  And then forgot to activate her.  Ouch.  Didn’t hurt me TOO badly as the Reds I dialed in were moves that the opponent did not anticipate as “only a fool would do THAT”…  Well, I did J…  Took a turn or two to swing back around to line it up again and then it was devastating with the Y and B’s forming a kill box and having fully modified shots to take down whatever I had in the box…  Still, it was good, but I think there is another iteration due for my remaining games in the League:

BBYNorraAP5 ver2 (199)

Braylen Stramm — A/SF-01 B-Wing	47
Elusive	3
Jamming Beam	0
Ship Total: 50
Half Points: 25 Threshold: 4
Ten Numb — A/SF-01 B-Wing	46
Trick Shot	2
Fire-Control System	2
Jamming Beam	0
Ship Total: 50
Half Points: 25 Threshold: 4
AP-5 — Sheathipede-class Shuttle	32
Leia Organa	2
Ship Total: 34
Half Points: 17 Threshold: 3
Norra Wexley (Y-Wing) — BTL-A4 Y-Wing	41
Ion Cannon Turret	4
Proton Torpedoes	12
R3 Astromech	3
Proton Bombs	5
Ship Total: 65
Half Points: 33 Threshold: 4

Trick Shot on Ten Numb can become a 3 point Talent for Norra should such a thing present as a better option?  Or just move TS over there to the Y-Wing I suppose…  Double down on the “I’m here to hit things” that she does.  NOT giving up the Torpedoes or Bombs as they were golden for me.  And of course my willingness to call in “Danger Close” and bomb my own stuff to put the Criticals on their Ships seemed like it shocked my opponents…  Side note, I HAVE called in Air Strikes and Artillery and do not think I ever called it in anything other than “Danger, Close” since I had a great deal of faith in the US Army’s ability to deliver ordnance where I was directing it…  Well, that and of course I needed it where the enemy WAS, so J…  But in any case, my last Proton Bomb hit Norra AND Ten Numb, stripping a Shield on Ten and hitting Norra for a Critical to put a Critical onto Fenn Rau…  Fuel Leak showing, 2 Hull remaining  so it was a death sentence since he could not have avoided it having K-Turned onto the bomb to line up the Range 1 shot into Norra to kill her…

I think Elusive on Braylen is a decent call…  I do a fair number of Reds with the B-Wings, and so regenerating the Charge should be possible easily enough.  Seeing that Talent used a fair bit, and it is “ok”…  Rerolls are nice, and it should extend the timer I am on with this list.  All about Offence, Defense is just the sheer amount of Hull/Shields I present on my gun line…  Leaves me with 3 points as I am trading the Vet Turret Gunner in…  Trick Shot doubled all the way to 2 points, and it is still too cheap I think, so that is a contender.  Ten with Elusive is I suppose a possibility, but I would prefer to put in something Offensive to keep with the theme and obvious synergies within the list…

Match up wise?  Seems like it does well against the “large” ships and Ace type builds.  Have yet to face a real Swarm in this edition outside of some very early practice games, so not thinking I’ll see them locally at least.  One Swarm I AM concerned about is the 5 Y-Wing squad I have seen on the table…  I have 4 Ships technically, so I should match fairly well if only my ships were not mostly Agility 1 and easy prey for Ion Turrets…  THAT could completely wreck my squad.  Guessing I’ll be doing the “Go FAST, hope to avoid them” using Leia to give me the ability to move quickly with 3 Banks and 4’s to close and have modified shots.  Close in, take the flank off the table and run like Hell…  Circle around and repeat, daring him to chase my Bomber…  Still, not a list I relish facing and I suspect it will not exist in the longer run as it is just a bit TOO efficient…   

Just more X-Wing testing for the League...

Looking like I am gearing up for a game or two this weekend in our local League…  Not honestly overly confident with what I am flying as most of it is new to me.  Well, newish…  I’ve now flown with the 2 B-Wings in a half dozen games in this edition and they are quite solid.  Good, close in knife fighters.  They ARE on a clock as they have essentially zero Defense, but as Aahz says, the best Defense is a solid Offence. 

BBYNorraAP5 (200)

Braylen Stramm — A/SF-01 B-Wing	47
Jamming Beam	0
Ship Total: 47
Half Points: 24 Threshold: 4
Ten Numb — A/SF-01 B-Wing	46
Fire-Control System	2
Jamming Beam	0
Ship Total: 48
Half Points: 24 Threshold: 4
AP-5 — Sheathipede-class Shuttle	32
Leia Organa	2
Ship Total: 34
Half Points: 17 Threshold: 3
Norra Wexley (Y-Wing) — BTL-A4 Y-Wing	41
Ion Cannon Turret	4
Proton Torpedoes	12
R3 Astromech	3
Proton Bombs	5
Veteran Turret Gunner	6
Ship Total: 71
Half Points: 36 Threshold: 4

Dropping the ARC in favor of Norra in her Y-Wing is different, but doubling down on the “we’re here to shoot things” aspect.  A BIT concerned that I am throwing way too many points into the Y, but I need the ability to throw out Damage quickly and MAYBE survive a bit into the game…  Proton Torpedo on the way in, Ion Turret and Bombs when I get close I think is a better plan for this list than the ARC trying to roll in and bump.  AP5 replacing Sabine means I DO lose a “pocket X-Wing” where the Attack Shuttle for whatever reason was as well armed at least as a standard X-Wing…  Better if I had a Turret mounted, but points get tight when you have 4 Ships in a list.  Leia is really good in this list as the 1 turn in 3 where my Reds go White is pretty darn powerful.  So, AP5 is there to Taxi her about and Coordinate to try and give extra Actions here and there.  Suspect that will start with him Coordinating a Focus to Norra so that she can try to move up and fire the fully modified Proton Torpedo early with the 2 B’s following up with their own fairly accurate shots.  Nothing subtle, just line up and joust or at least move in a block formation I think.  NOT tied to a formation, but DO want to keep AP5 in Range 2 to Coordinate in extra Actions, even to the Stressed B-Wings.  PROBABLY way too much “stuff” on Norra’s Y-Wing, but I like having a lot of extra options.  The Astromech is “neat”, but easily cut.  Same I suspect for the Proton Bombs I suspect, but those are not the top of the “it can go” list.  The Vet Turret Gunner is edge case, kind of neat, but really I see it another way to just outright win out more Jousts…  All 4 ships HAVE Talent Slots, but nothing really jumping out to me as “I NEED this”…  Even System slots on the B-Wings..  Neat, but not building based on those here, so…

Looking at the X-Wing, Y-Wing and B-Win for the Rebels all are ~41 points for their most “Basic” build…  Essentially naked X and B with the Y having Ion Turret and Gunner.  Which wins out?  No clue I think all COULD do well, but the Y has options, the X is just more maneuverable at speed while the B is going to roll in and knife fight…  Interesting choices, I have to admit that I am liking this version of the game as it develops.  I suspect that there will be some people playing massed Y-Wings as they will just be a PITA to kill off before they get in their shots and especially if they have Ion shots in addition…  Of course, an Arc dodger will tear it apart one on one…  But 4-5 Y-Wings?  Tough to dodge that many Arcs, and getting the potential double shot out of each of them?  Eventually you WILL miss an Arc dodge or fail an Agility roll, and then?  Well, that is likely it…  Just thinking back to playing against Will’s 4 X-Wing list and THAT was rough.  Mind, he IS probably the best player with that I’ve ever seen by a long shot, but that shows the upper range of the potential for that list…  With the S-Foils, those ships are actually quite maneuverable, and with Biggs/Selflessness in the mix, they are frustratingly difficult to push Damage through on.  SLIGHTLY annoyed that 41 points is the break point on the Rebel things, I’d like to fly 5 generics in a list…  But that MIGHT just be too powerful at the moment I suppose, so best perhaps that is not an option. 

Still waiting on the Republic stuff…  Hoping to fly 2 Jedi and 2 other Ships…  My preference would be on ARCs of course, but…  Place holders I think for the N-1’s when THEY arrive.  Just having the 4 FAST ships out there I think will be a really fun list to fly.  Suspect I’ll struggle a bit to push Damage through like I did with my Imperial Ace lists, but my lads will survive well and win on points more often than not once I get the hang of flying them correctly…  Rebel Arcs start in the 50’s though, so I suspect that Republic ones will be at least that much making the 2 Jedi/2 ARC list something that simply does not happen…  Though I think the “generic” Inquisitors in the TIE Adv v1’s are sub 40 points, so MAYBE 2 of the Jedi Knights?  But with Anakin being my favorite of the Jedi Pilots, I do want to use that ship…  Just have to see what the points come to and since I think that was one that we do not yet know the Pilot Ability for…  Might change my mind?  No, I6 and 3 Force will be EXTREMELY powerful no matter the Ability.  The Supernatural Reflexes (thankfully) have been priced out of usefulness for him I think at 32 points, but even without that crutch?  I think it will be the best ship in the game, at least for my play style…

Jobs, life and just a bit of X-Wing to keep us sane :-)

So, the job hunt continues it seems…  The interviews I’ve gotten recently were…  Different.  Guessing that I have been on Campus for far too long and the idea of taking a job outside of Campus is almost foreign at this point.  I DO go over my 20 years in a few Months, so I am actually (more or less) free to look outside of the University at this point.  Good and bad that is…  As I interview in the “real world”, I am reminded why I did NOT for so long and why I was willing to take the lower pay in the University system.  The benefits and stability are REALLY important for the whole family thing.  But there do seem to be a dearth of opportunities here to move within the University at this time.  A shame, and as one of those Manager types who tried for years to get people hired in to replace folks who left without success I am “concerned” about the staffing levels.  Seems very much like another situation where nothing really gets fixed until it burns down.  Dealing with exactly that situation in my own building with the main power to half the building “down” with one of the busses having melted with flood water pouring over it.  Emergency repair in place and this weekend to fix it in a more permanent sense.  And this time they are actually going to put in the “shield” to divert the flood water from the power equipment that was “scheduled for some time next year” after having been an emergency request and filed under “deferred maintenance” for at least the last seven years…  So, they “saved” a bunch of money over those years by not implementing the (relatively) inexpensive fix of simply diverting the flood waters because of the “no consequences” over the years.  Then of course it DID fail catastrophically and there is a VERY expensive fix that is required.  The buss had to be manufactured as they are all custom, there were of course the OT charges for the Electricians who did an amazing job with the temporary emergency fix to at least keep SOME power to the building in the meantime and even more as the replacement is put in place over the weekend so we do not just shut down the whole Department during a normal business day…  Not everyone is happy about that as we are a VERY active Research Department and there ARE in fact labs that must shut down on Saturday because of this…  But overall of course we have to apply the 85% solution.  If it works for 85%, then it should be judged a success.  And so it goes….

Flu season is brutal and I got news that my building was one that was exposed to unvaccinated folks with active diseases…  Measles I think.  Mind, I was vaccinated ages ago as a child and again in the Army of course as we were exposed to very “exotic” things travelling many places…  Annoying as there ARE a few folks who have no immunity, and this poses an unnecessary risk to those people.  In GENERAL, I’m more of a “let everyone do their own thing” sort of person, but as this affects others including some of my own people…  The “do your own thing” only works so long as it does not harm others…  And since this DOES pose a risk to others I have less sympathy for those who wish to not be vaccinated. 

Ah, on to more “fun” things…  More X-Wing games in and more information released about the upcoming Wave 3 and 4 for the game…  Wave 4 announced and several reprints with the Naboo N-1 fighter that I’ll be getting for my Republic forces.  Having the TIE Defender ability to get the Evade for the Speed 3+ maneuver REALLY fits my play style and I suspect it will pair well with the Jedi Fighters.  The new B-Wing sculpt is AMAZING.  Folding S-Foils, rotating ship AND Cockpit…  They really are stepping up their game with the new ships.  And as that was always one of my favorite Ships…  Flying 2 of them now, looking forward to them being Hyperspace legal soon J… Though I suspect my Rebels will become Republic very shortly when Wave 3 hits.  No points yet, so not SURE they’ll work, but all indications so far have been that they will be balanced and playable from the start.  2^nd Edition has been REALLY good so far for that.  The new stuff has 2-4 more previews yet to do if they follow true to their normal pattern.  The ARC-170, the Sith ship and maybe the individual packages for the Aethersprite and Droid ship…  But looking like it will be out well in advance of the next big event here in Bloomington on 4 May…

X-Wing League play testing

So, got in some more testing and modifying my B-Wing list it seems…  Looking like this is what I’ll use:

BBYNorraAP5 (197)

Braylen Stramm — A/SF-01 B-Wing	47
Jamming Beam	0
Ship Total: 47
Half Points: 24 Threshold: 4
Ten Numb — A/SF-01 B-Wing	46
Fire-Control System	2
Jamming Beam	0
Ship Total: 48
Half Points: 24 Threshold: 4
AP-5 — Sheathipede-class Shuttle	32
Leia Organa	2
Ship Total: 34
Half Points: 17 Threshold: 3
Norra Wexley (Y-Wing) — BTL-A4 Y-Wing	41
Ion Cannon Turret	4
Proton Torpedoes	12
Proton Bombs	5
Veteran Turret Gunner	6
Ship Total: 68
Half Points: 34 Threshold: 4

Norra is good on the Arc, so I’ll try the Y-Wing variant I suppose.  The one thing that I was having trouble with was actually doing Damage.  Proton Torpedoes are solid, even at 12 points, seems good to have Ion Turret and Bombs…  The list is a Damage Race as I have essentially zero Defensive capability (not sure the term to really use here) and I just need to throw out more Damage faster than my Opponent…  Coordinate is just SO much better than any other Action I think and it does make AP5 just a Taxi for Leia and a mobile Action for the actual hard hitters of the list.  Sabine is amazing, but I found I REALLY missed the Turret and frankly she is more of a Combat ship and she wants to be I there fighting.  SHE has a ton of Actions and can be an awesome blocker/Arc Dodger, but she really does nothing to aid the rest of the list I think.  Honestly the FCS on Ten is expendable I think.  Neat, but not really necessary.  Braylen is solid on his own getting the effective TL when Stressed.  Ten gets the Focus(ish) for Stress, which is great, but found I was not hitting often enough quickly enough.  Still need to figure out the last 3-5 points for the list…

I suspect that I was playing it wrong with it needing to just have the ARC to just bull rush in front of the B-Wings and Sabine just running a Flank or playing Linebacker.  Might still be a thing, but I suspect there will be far more hard counters to the “JOUST ME” list.  Thinking the YBB list with the Support ship to just throw in Coordinates and taxi Leia to allow some really interesting Turns where I can do the Red Maneuvers AND get Actions to have the better modified shots.  And of course the possibility of Norra dropping a Bomb, K-Turning while she has the target Locked and have the fully modified Proton Torpedo shot is amusing…  Will see I suppose…

Need a few more games for the League…  Looks like we’ll try to get in some games this Sunday and next Sunday…  Only way I think I’ll get in the last 4 games I think.